We welcome Josh back to the table, making a perfect 5 hosts to discuss the stranger side of society. Two Iowa brothers are convicted of stabbing a McDonald's crew member; A new segment of What's Sippin' has us nostalgic for 90s dad rock; Ian has a brand new beef with the haters; Princess the pig was a martyr for animal rights; A town is beset with mysterious mashed potato dishes; a new set of 36 questions gives new insight into what makes the table tick.