I Believe
I Believe
Joel K. Douglas
Dear Democrats. You're Close to Something Real. Don't Waste It.
25 minutes Posted Mar 3, 2026 at 7:01 am.
0:00
25:42
Download MP3
Show notes

Once upon a time, I might have been a Democrat.

The theory sounds good. Love your neighbor. Build systems that catch people when they fall. Use the government to do what charity alone can’t. I’ve read the arguments. Listened to the sermons.

But the more I pull on the logic threads, the more it comes apart.

Not because the compassion is wrong. The compassion is right. After all, rend our hearts, not our garments.

We need to dig deeper.

I’m listening to James Talarico, the Texas state rep running for Senate. The seminarian. Stephen Colbert wasn’t allowed to put him on television. He gave a sermon in Lubbock, where he said the word “love” three dozen times, and people in the second most conservative city in America didn’t laugh.

He says politics is just another word for how we treat our neighbors.

He’s right. That’s not a liberal idea. It’s a constitutional idea. The framers called it the General Welfare. It’s one of our six national goals, along with Justice, Liberty, Order, Defense, and Union.

So I’m writing this to Democrats. Not as an opponent. You’ve been searching for a path forward because you’re getting pummeled.

I think your guy is close to something real. And I don’t want you to waste it.

Let’s start with a story. There’s a town in northern Missouri called Chillicothe. It sits where the Grand River gathers its creeks and the hills open into bean fields. I’ve chased big whitetail bucks there. The town is real. The math is real. The people I’m about to describe are not. And there are a thousand towns like this between here and Washington.

Act I. Chillicothe

The Grand River comes down out of Iowa in two forks. They run south through Livingston County and meet a few miles west of town. From there, the river carries everything the land gives it. The Thompson comes in from the north. Coon Creek, Blackwell Branch, Shoal Creek. All feed into the same channel. Half a dozen named waterways and a hundred unnamed draws all running to the same low ground.

They all flow to the Missouri. The Missouri to the Mississippi. The Mississippi to the Gulf.

This is where the country changes. West of here, the hills are closer together and thick with timber. Draws steep and tangled, the kind of ground that breaks equipment and hides cattle. East of here, the land opens. The hills roll longer and lower. The big oaks give way to grass. Bean fields. Corn ground. Fencelines you can see for a mile.

Chillicothe sits on this seam. Nine thousand people at the crossroads of 36 and 65, where the water gathers, and the hills let go. Grain elevator on the horizon. A Casey’s, where teenagers get donuts on Sunday mornings. A couple of churches. A bar that does a fish fry on Fridays during Lent.

Washington Street runs through the middle of town.

There’s a diner called the Grill. A farm supply store. A hardware store that’s been in the same family for three generations.

The diner employs six people. The owner is a woman named Pam. She’s had the place eleven years. She’s not getting rich. The margins on a small-town diner are what you’d guess. She clears maybe forty thousand a year after she pays her people, her food costs, her insurance, her rent, and the fryer that breaks every winter.

She pays her cooks too little. Her waitstaff get nine plus tips. It’s not enough. She knows it’s not enough. She’d pay more if she could.

Then the minimum wage goes up.

Not because anyone in Chillicothe asked for it. Because good people in Jefferson City and Washington decided that workers deserve more. And they’re right. Workers do deserve more. Nobody here disagrees with the principle.

Pam runs the numbers on a Tuesday night after close. She’s at the same table where the farmers sit in the morning. Calculator, notebook, the grease smell still in the walls.

At fifteen dollars an hour, her labor cost goes up thirty-one thousand dollars a year. She doesn’t have thirty-one thousand dollars. She has the diner.

She can raise prices. A dollar on every plate. Maybe the regulars stay. Maybe they don’t. The regulars are the farmers and the guys from the MoDOT crew and the women from the school district office. They’re not rich either. A dollar a plate, five days a week, fifty weeks a year. That’s two hundred and fifty dollars a year out of their pockets. Money they would have spent at the hardware store. Or the farm supply. Or the fish fry.

Or she can cut hours. She cuts the weekend breakfast shift. That’s Kaylee. Nineteen years old. Single mother. She was making nine dollars an hour plus tips on the weekend morning rush, which came out to about fourteen an hour, and it was the only shift that worked with her kid’s schedule.

Kaylee doesn’t get a raise. Kaylee gets a phone call on a Tuesday night.

Now Kaylee drives thirty-two miles to Cameron to pick up shifts at a Waffle House off I-35. She spends more on gas. She sees her kid less. The Waffle House pays fifteen. After gas and the extra childcare, she nets less than she made at the Grill.

The farm supply store does its own math. Labor costs up. They raise the price on wire, on posts, on mineral tubs. Not a lot. Four percent, maybe five. Enough that the cattle rancher south of town notices when he’s buying supplies for calving season. He doesn’t say anything. He just tightens somewhere else. Doesn’t fix the fence on the north pasture. Puts off the vet check. Skips the bull sale in Trenton.

The contractor who was going to build a starter home on the east side of town pencils it out again. Framing crew costs more. Materials cost more because the lumber yard raised prices for the same reason everyone else did. He was going to build two three-bedroom houses and list them at a hundred and eighty thousand. The kind of house a young couple with two incomes could buy. Now the numbers don’t work below two-ten. At two-ten, the young couple doesn’t qualify.

He doesn’t build the houses.

A year passes. Washington Street looks the same. The Grill is still open. The farm supply is still open. The churches still have Sunday service and the Casey’s still sells donuts.

But Kaylee is gone. The houses weren’t built. The rancher’s north fence is sagging and he’s running heifers he should have culled. The hardware store cut its part-time kid. The diner is quieter on weekends.

The creeks still run to the Grand. The country still opens east of town. The grain elevator still stands against the sky like it has for sixty years.

Nobody did anything wrong.

The people who wrote the bill wanted to help. Pam wanted to pay more. Kaylee wanted to work. The contractor wanted to build. The rancher wanted to buy a bull.

Everyone loved their neighbor.

And the water still runs downhill. Gravity. It doesn’t care what you meant.

Act II. The Butterfly

Here’s one place we need to keep digging. To raise wages, small businesses have to grow revenue. You can’t pay people with money you don’t have.

Pam clears forty thousand a year. She pays federal income tax. Self-employment tax. State tax. After the government takes its share she keeps about thirty. That’s what she lives on. That’s what she runs the business on. Equipment. Repairs. The fryer.

The margin between keeping Kaylee and cutting Kaylee’s shift is somewhere in the ten thousand dollars the government took.

Cut her taxes. Not to make her rich. To give her room. The difference between forty and forty-six thousand dollars is the weekend shift. It’s Kaylee staying in Chillicothe instead of driving to Cameron. It’s the phone call Pam doesn’t have to make on a Tuesday night.

But the cut comes with a condition. You get the break when your filings prove you paid livable wages. Every worker. Enough that none of them qualify for SNAP. Enough that none of them need the Earned Income Tax Credit. Enough that Kaylee can work the weekend shift and take her kid to the doctor without a government program covering the difference.

Pam gets the cut and keeps wages flat, she loses it next year. The incentive only runs one direction. Pay your people, keep the break. Th…



Get full access to I Believe at joelkdouglas.substack.com/subscribe