Jackboot on Protest
Jill Stein recently became my candidate of choice in the 2024 presidential election. She’s running on the Green Party ticket and I will vote with her. For many months, I’ve also followed Cornel West, who is also an admirable candidate.
Stein was arrested near Washington University in St. Louis, Missouri for protesting the Israeli-Gaza war and the war’s resulting genocide in the Gaza Strip. This was remarkable for a number of reasons: Stein is Jewish and she seems to be the only presidential candidate who has the fortitude to go out on the front lines of protest, and watching this video (Glenn Greenwald, May 1, 2024) of her arrest, viewers can begin to see the kind of official viciousness that militarized police bring to the legal right under the Constitution’s First Amendment to seek a redress of grievances. The grievance here is the mass murder of civilians and children in the Gaza Strip.
What is not seen in Stein’s arrest is her description of the brutality that was used against her by police. A cop attempted to forcibly flip Stein and an attempt was made to charge her for coming in contact with him as she was roughed up during her arrest. The latter is an old strategem among militarized police: Just say a cop felt threatened or intimidated. Look at the military gear and weaponry that police carry and it can easily be determined that this perception of being threatened is false.
Look to the yearly number of Black people killed by the police and the mass incarceration of Black people. Some may draw parallels to the open-air prison some call pre-war Gaza.
In Mississippi, a counter-protest to the Israel-Gaza war turned racist (Guardian, May 4, 2024).
An offshoot of protest against the Gaza genocide is that the police seem to take pleasure in attacking people. A woman was taken to the ground at one protest (New York Times, May 3, 2024).
Third parties are seen as a threat to the duopoly. The US has moved so far to the right politically, socially, and in terms of economic inequality and the government is now willing to criminalize and weaponize dissent. With the Gaza genocide, the media and government seem to relish in weaponizing claims of antisemitism despite some Jewish students often involved in protest against the war.
The criminalization of dissent in the US goes back far in our history. Critics of war and war resisters have always been punished in different ways, from shunning to deportation and jail. Eugene Debs is one example of an antiwar politician who was jailed for opposing World War I. Conscientious objectors have always faced censure at the minimum and sometimes jail during war.
During the antiwar movement of the Vietnam War, protesters at the Democratic Convention in Chicago in August 1968 were mercilessly beaten by rioting police in what Senator Abraham Ribicoff called “Gestapo tactics” (New York Times, August 25, 1996) from the convention floor. Richard Daley, the mayor of Chicago, spoke to the convention when Ribicoff protested, and according to some, Daley uttered antisemitic slurs. Now antisemitism has been weaponized by those in power in both the US and Israel and elsewhere as a propaganda device against protest. It’s not the Gaza genocide that matters, but invented antisemitism used as a cover by the warmongers. This, however, does not mean that actual incidents of antisemitism among a minority of protesters does not exist. But actual and vicious antisemitism was seen in 2017 in Charlottesville, Virginia and in Pittsburgh a year later. In both those cases, antisemitism of the far right turned lethal. Recall the “Unite the Right” rally call: “Jews will not replace us,” and their Nazi slogan: “blood and soil.”
Expressions of antisemitism are made now by a small minority of protesters and need to be countered and condemned, but the broad brushstroke of antisemitism against protesters is untrue and blurs the reason for protest against the Gaza genocide.
Thank you for subscribing. Share this episode.



