Howie’s Substack Podcast (private feed for howielisnoff@gmail.com)
Howie’s Substack Podcast (private feed for [email protected])
Howie Lisnoff
Was 50+ Years in Democratic Party Politics a Waste?
14 minutes Posted Apr 5, 2024 at 7:53 pm.
0:00
14:35
Download MP3
Show notes

barack

Was 50+ Years in Democratic Party Politics a Waste?

My family, specifically my mother Syl, was not political until the Vietnam era. When the Vietnam War broke into the consciences of many, she became political. Liberal politics then meant alignment with the Democratic Party that remained committed to some of the labor and welfare principles of Franklin Roosevelt’s New Deal. The post-World War II boom, with some busts, of jobs, housing, food, material goods, and a sense of well-being seemed readily available. Johnson would include medical care for seniors in the mix of social programs. For the majority of Black and Brown people and indigenous peoples, the promise of the so-called American Dream was not available. Lyndon Johnson thought he could create a Great Society, only to witness it fail in the fields, highlands, mountains, and coastal plains of the quagmire in Southeast Asia. The Great Society did attempt to address the needs of Black and Brown people, but racism and white supremacy were well-established here over many centuries. The basic rights to vote, education, and housing were not available to many, or were so substandard as to be absent. Women’s rights and the environment were not apparent to most besides a small minority and some scholars.

The Vietnam War entered our homes every weekday evening on the news of the three major television networks: CBS, NBC, and ABC. The war came into our family rooms and living rooms, first with lots of nationalistic propaganda, and eventually in so-called living color that included blood and gore. Most people in the US were not ready for that debacle.

My mother began writing letters to the Providence Journal, the state’s only major newspaper in Rhode Island and expanded her work to commentaries. She would soon be interviewed about the war for newspaper articles. In our family’s coffee shop, Syl would often get into heated debates with those townspeople who considered anti-communism a religion and war and soldiering a duty. There were no repercussions for me with the exception of my Selective Service notification to report for a physical exam arriving exactly two days after I graduated from college.

Writing and arguments turned into her commitment to Eugene McCarthy’s 1968 run for the presidency against Lyndon Johnson. Syl was named a state co-chair of the McCarthy campaign and set up a local office for that campaign in our town. McCarthy ran as a peace candidate and ran well, too well, against Johnson in the first primary of the campaign in New Hampshire. Johnson pulled out of the campaign and Robert Kennedy soon entered the race only to be assassinated in June following the California primary.

The McCarthy campaign headquarters in town became a gathering place for many of the town’s youth and the police took notice. Kids, including a next-door neighbor, would be regularly hassled by local cops. When Robert Kennedy was assassinated the night of his California primary win, Eugene McCarthy went on to unsuccessfully challenge Vice President Hubert Humphrey, who refused to break away from Lyndon Johnson’s war footing in Vietnam and lost  the election to Richard Nixon.

Change after change took place as the 1960s roared on. Martin Luther King, Jr. had been assassinated in Memphis in April 1968 while supporting striking sanitation workers. Black radicalism exploded. The My Lai massacre along with reports of other massacres in Vietnam made their way back to the states. Nixon, with his secret plan for peace, had already expanded the Vietnam War into Cambodia and Laos, and called protesting students at Kent State University in Ohio “bums.” Long before, Ronald Reagan, then governor of California, had called for bloodshed to stop protest. J. Edgar Hoover of the FBI said they, protesters, got what they deserved. James Rhodes, Ohio’s governor, called the protesters “Brown Shirts,” a reference to Nazis.

With Vietnam in our living rooms every weekday evening and knowing that the war was both lost and bestial, George McGovern mounted a campaign for the Democratic nomination, and with the lessons learned from 1968, he won the nomination. A questionable pick in 1972 of a running mate lost support for his campaign, as did McGovern’s view for an equitable society. Law and order was long the dog whistle of Republicans and the paranoid Nixon campaign broke into Democratic campaign offices in Washington, DC in the Watergate complex. The break-in led in a straight line to Nixon’s resignation for a whole host of wrongdoing including hush money for the Watergate burglars to cover up the conspiracy and hide the payments from public view. Still, Nixon had won by a landslide in 1972.

Carter took the presidency from the inept Gerald Ford in 1976. Ford did nearly nothing besides granting Nixon a complete pardon. Ford was not willing to do the same for resisters to the Vietnam War. I had worked for a city councilman in the city where we lived in central Rhode Island, so my major contribution to Jimmy Carter’s campaign was handing out Carter buttons and literature at a polling place in that city. Carter’s presidency was a bust! He liked to lecture those in the US about their apparent weaknesses while gas lines burgeoned. The Iran hostage crisis intervened.

Pulling back to the 1972 campaign, my parents’ house was transformed into a campaign headquarters with the old dual-color green computer sheets with perforated corners filling every nook and cranny of the house. There were parties on several days and Syl went out to speak at different venues again and again. Syl was the state co-chair once again. She put great faith and effort into the McGovern campaign. One campaign speech sticks in my memory when Syl met Senator Claiborne Pell at the local Elks Lodge and both were attacked viciously for their support of McGovern. Pell was a friend of McGovern’s in the Senate. Syl left the talk in tears and Senator Pell consoled her.

The candidates my wife and I supported with house parties and only superficial involvement in their campaigns range from Walter Mondale through Michael Dukakis and Al Gore. When we moved to Florida in 2004, part of our intention was to turn around the theft of the 2000 election by George W. Bush from Gore. Gore gave up without a fight and Bush’s shock troops were on the ground and in the courts in his brother Jeb’s state. The Supreme Court stopped the Florida counting of votes that studies have found went to Gore. When the loss of democracy in the US is noted, the 2000 election will be high on the list. The refusal of Mitch McConnell to allow Obama’s nomination to the Supreme Court a hearing will be next following the 2000 election. The Patriot Act of 2001 will also necessarily lead the list!

In 2004, we thought we could redeem the stolen election of 2000, and in this instance John Kerry lost by millions of votes in Florida. Ohio results were questioned because the polls closed with lots of people still in line and turned away.

The campaign in Florida was a huge bust. Local campaign coordinators were brought in from colleges and universities far away. Ours was a recent graduate from Harvard who did not know the area. Barack Obama did not make the same mistake with his campaign. We signed on as precinct captains and travelled over Palm Beach County. We worked on phone banks, canvassed door-to-door, and went to campaign events all over the county. We were turned away from an event meant for first responders and saw Kerry in person speaking in West Palm Beach at both ends of his campaign.

“First we’ll kill all the terrorists,” is how Kerry began one speech. I was shocked at how he opened his appearance. Kirsten Dunst was somewhere on the stage. There is always an entourage of stars following Democrats and this is likely less about their politics and more about promoting their careers.

The entire experience working for the Kerry campaign was a waste of time. Voting lists were so out of date as to be useless. Canvassing was an exercise in frustration, as irate people were impossible to deal with, one person in a mobile home enclave in West Palm Beach so drunk she was unable to speak. When we, the canvassing group, returned to the campaign headquarters in West Palm Beach, the coordinator of that office berated us for not engaging with the alcoholic. “These are the people we have to reach.”

On election day, my wife was a poll monitor in Palm Beach Gardens and was shocked to witness several women coming in to vote with printed far-right fundamentalist voting directions.

While I worked for a Congressional candidate two years later, the experience in the Kerry campaign had chastened me about work in Democratic campaigns.

Bernie Sanders’ two campaigns were reminders of George McGovern’s campaign in 1972. All of the rhetoric was there about income inequality, medical care for all, relief for student debt, but Sanders failed to deliver on a strong antiwar platform although he had voted against going to war in Iraq in 2003. Sanders rolled over in the face of Hillary Clinton’s failed campaign and stood by while Clinton slandered him for daring to run against her in the primaries. Some of these folks, like Clinton, really hate anything resembling democracy. The fixing of the campaign by Democratic Party higher-ups was unmasked by Julian Assange’s publication of the emails that proved the party’s manipulation of the campaign.

Sanders repeated his subservience to the Democratic higher-ups with his endorsement of the neoliberal warmonger Joe Biden in 2020. We had worked in three states for Sanders during his two campaigns only to see Sanders roll over and support two neoliberals who moved the Democrats farther to the right. It was both informing and depressing to see how far to the right the Democrats had moved since McGovern’s run for the presidency. They had become, along with the Republicans, the party of wealth and war and the most limited supporters of what was left of the social safety net. A Congressional campaign I worked in across the New York border in 2016 was unremarkable and that candidate lost by a whopping eight percentage points to a far-right candidate. Here, again, was where the US political system and the electorate had moved.

What lessons were learned over this long road of politicking? Stay away from electoral politics: It leads to a cul-de-sac of disappointment and disillusion. Had anyone said this to me in 1968, or in 1972, I would have said they were nuts!

Bill Clinton disappointed with his end to welfare as we know it and draconian prison sentences supported by Joe Biden in the Senate. Bill Clinton accelerated the movement of jobs offshore with the North American Free Trade Agreement. Barack Obama disappointed with his bailout of the banking industry and his secret policeman’s beer fest ball. The horizons for a better and less violent world shrank everywhere!   



Thank you for subscribing. Share this episode.