Howie’s Substack Podcast (private feed for howielisnoff@gmail.com)
Howie’s Substack Podcast (private feed for [email protected])
Howie Lisnoff
“No matter what you start with [sic] it ends up being so much less."
6 minutes Posted Apr 3, 2024 at 4:50 pm.
0:00
6:54
Download MP3
Show notes

“No matter what you start with [sic] it ends up being so much less.”

Before Richard Brown pushes himself out of his apartment window in the movie “The Hours” (2002), he speaks this line:

“I wanted to be a writer, that's all. I wanted to write about it all. Everything that happens in a moment. The way the flowers looked when you carried them in your arms. This towel, how it smells, how it feels, this thread. All our feelings, yours and mine. The history of it, who we once were. Everything in the world. Everything all mixed up, like it's all mixed up now. And I failed. I failed. No matter what you start with it ends up being so much less. Sheer fucking pride and stupidity.”

And that is exactly what happened from the heady days and great days of the 1960s and early 1970s. Before committing suicide, Abbie Hoffman, protester, jokester, and theorist of those great days of change said it would never happen again. His was not a fictional suicide.

Even a casual observer might be taken aback. Does it have to end that way? Most shed their ideals and their activism and protest through careerism or by going to the hills, or dropping out of society as many did. But among the dropouts many came back and made an individual peace with society. Some became consummate hypocrites and lauded values and actions they once condemned. Some became cheerleaders for war.

David Harris, the draft resister, who spent over two years in federal prison for his act of protest in the face of the bestiality of the Vietnam War, remarked before his death that the strength of the pushback of the far right in the US to the achievements of the Vietnam era was not expected. We, as a generation, did not expect the ugliness of those pushbacks. Look to diminished women’s rights for one of those pushbacks. Look to the tortured environment for another pushback. In fact, those pushbacks are still going on in the culture wars and the acceptance of militarism.

To an extent, if a person wanted shelter, food, and some sense of normalcy in life, compromises had to be made. I spent 40 years doing all kinds of work in education, and education in the US is a conservative enterprise that has always faced rear-guard battles by right-wing forces and against itself. Teachers, unions, public education, and the kids themselves suffered as a result of right-wing pushback. While there were talented educators, one right-wing administrator I dealt with for nearly two decades said: “Teaching is mediocrity.”

There were bright spots of protest along the way despite the right-wing juggernaut. First, there was the amnesty movement to grant Vietnam era war resisters a place in society in the US where they could resume their lives. Reaganism presented its own challenges with his low-intensity wars in Central America. But even with Reagan’s right-wing juggernaut that began the party of wealth through low taxes on the wealthy, there were people who went to Central America to counter the wars, and protest in the US.

When George H.W. Bush crushed the Vietnam Syndrome, the hesitancy of people in the US to support distant foreign wars, this time in Iraq, there were lots of people who went out into the streets and protested. I trudged up Broad Street with family members in Providence, Rhode Island in winter’s freezing cold to hear a minister condemn that war. But protest was different without skin in the game, and the end of the military draft in 1973 took skin out of the game and muzzled some protest.

George W. Bush, a pious moron, turned the forces of the US against both Afghanistan and Iraq following the horror of the attacks of September 2001, and took our Constitutional rights along with those two quagmires that have cost trillions of dollars of US treasure. Well-fed kids, good food, housing, good schools, and medical care for all were all possible. Imagine the social good that even a small portion of that money could have accomplished. Women are being stoned to death in Afghanistan again. We helped give rise to the whackos the Soviet invasion unleashed there.

Now, with Biden and his ally Netanyahu, something I never thought I would see, perhaps because of lingering naiveté of those great years of change of the 1960s, genocide is being committed once again and again in the full view of humanity.

Life and change were all so good for a time, but we are a seriously flawed species, some are inventive dwarfs as Bertolt Brecht observed in my paraphrase of his statement. Empire and imperialism, no matter where it rears its ugly head in civilizations past and present, is bad news. All of the empires pass away at some point.

Isaac Singer writes about a young man’s dream in Menaseh’s Dream and that work is so full of hope and imagination that it takes the reader away from the grinding reality of what is present today. Maybe that’s the unholy dichotomy, supreme ugliness of this species living side-by-side with great hope?



Thank you for subscribing. Share this episode.