History's A Disaster
History's A Disaster
Andrew
Alfred Packer The Colorado Cannibal
21 minutes Posted Nov 9, 2025 at 5:00 am.
Cold Open And Hook
Sponsor Bit And Setup
Packer’s Early Life And Failures
The San Juan Expedition Forms
Chief Ouray’s Warning Ignored
Packer Reappears Alone
First Confession And Arrest
Bodies Found At Dead Man’s Gulch
Capture Years Later And Second Confession
Trials, Sentences, And Appeals
Parole And Later Life
Modern Forensics And The Colt Revolver
Host’s Takeaways And Closing CTA
0:00
21:04
Download MP3
Show notes

Send a text

A winter crossing turned deadly when Alfred Packer led five men into the San Juans against Chief Ouray’s warning, then returned alone with shifting stories and other men’s gear. We trace the confessions, the trials, and the forensics that still complicate his guilt.

• Packer’s troubled past and failed careers
• The mining party’s formation and dire route choice
• Chief Ouray’s warning and the fatal decision to proceed
• Packer’s lone arrival and suspicious possessions
• First and second confessions with conflicting details
• Discovery of the bodies at Dead Man’s Gulch
• Trials, appeals, and a landmark sentence
• Media advocacy, parole, and late-life image
• Modern forensic findings and the revolver analysis
• Our take on motive, survival, and responsibility



Facebook: historyisadisaster
Instagram: historysadisaster
email: [email protected]

Special thank you to Lunarfall Audio for producing and doing all the heavy lifting on audio editing since April 13, 2025, the Murder of Christopher Meyer episode https://lunarfallaudio.com/