On a cold snowy night in December of 1957, seven-year-old Maria and her best friend Kathy were playing their favorite game near their favorite spot. It was just another normal playdate until they met a young man named "Johnny". Poor Maria wouldn't be found until 4 months later.... It is said to be the oldest cold case to make it to trial, did law enforcement have the right guy, and did the judge set a murderer free? Or was it truly someone else....