Music: They Come At Night by Shane Ivers - https://www.silvermansound.com
Most who knew him thought Herb Baumeister was the typical midwestern man. He gave the impression that he was a straight-laced, red-blooded, business-owning, and devoted family man. He married his wife shortly after leaving college and they would go on to have three beautiful children. The couple had a dream and it was the dream that most people have: to be successful in what they set out to do. When they opened and grew their own business which allowed them to purchase the 18-acre estate known as Fox Hollow Farms, it seemed their dream was coming true.
It wasn’t discovered until later that Herb was leading a double life. Baumeister was hiding the fact that he was truly a homosexual man. A fact that he felt he had to keep hidden to be well-liked and successful in the otherwise conservative area that they lived in. Baumeister also had a darker side. He had a proclivity for erotic asphyxiation which prompted his desire to kill. In 1994, the police were closing in on him when they discovered partial remains of at least eight missing men from the area. Listen as we discuss Baumeister, his alleged crimes, and his fate. This is one that you don’t want to miss.



