Broad History
Broad History
Isabelle Roughol
The Real American Frontier | Part 2 | The homesteaders trad wives would rather forget about (with Megan Kate Nelson)
36 minutes Posted Jun 6, 2026 at 7:00 am.
Email me: [email protected] to:
08 Megan Kate Nelson part 2
Start of interview
Introducing Polly Bemis
The majority-Chinese American West
Polly Bemis traveled without moving
Chinese women were the first targets of US anti-immigrant policy
The aggressive anti-Chinese immigration policies of the United States
How big government made the West for white men
Ella Watson's broken American dream
The cattle queens
A high tolerance for risk
Why correcting the Frontier myth matters today
How trad wives utilise the American Frontier
What moment in history should we revisit from women's perspective?
Outro
0:00
36:24
Download MP3
Show notes
In part 2 of our exploration of the American frontier, Megan Kate Nelson introduces two women who belie the homesteader image conservative "trad wives" like to harken back to. Polly Bemis was a Chinese immigrant who built a life and a community in Idaho, despite intense prejudice and stringent anti-Chinese immigration policies. Ella Watson was a self-made homesteader and small rancher, a so-called cattle queen who got on the wrong side of cattle barons in Wyoming and paid the price.Read more: How Chinese women were barred from the American dream 
★ Support this podcast ★
On this episode:
Isabelle Roughol - Host
Megan Kate Nelson - Guest
What do you think?Read & comment at broadhistory.comReply on Bluesky
Email me: [email protected] to: (
00:00) - 08 Megan Kate Nelson part 2
(
01:18) - Start of interview
(
01:46) - Introducing Polly Bemis
(
03:04) - The majority-Chinese American West
(
06:55) - Polly Bemis traveled without moving
(
09:12) - Chinese women were the first targets of US anti-immigrant policy
(
09:50) - The aggressive anti-Chinese immigration policies of the United States
(
12:13) - How big government made the West for white men
(
13:43) - Ella Watson's broken American dream
(
14:25) - The cattle queens
(
23:03) - A high tolerance for risk
(
24:30) - Why correcting the Frontier myth matters today
(
27:06) - How trad wives utilise the American Frontier
(
30:21) - What moment in history should we revisit from women's perspective?
(
34:30) - Outro
Get the book🇺🇸 Buy the book🇬🇧 Shop the UK bookshop (Megan Kate Nelson's The Westerners is only available in the US)(Affiliate bookshop.org links support Broad History and indie bookstores.)Click here to view the episode transcript.