Asking For A Friend - Timely Issues. Timeless Torah.
Asking For A Friend - Timely Issues. Timeless Torah.
Kehillas Federation
#22: Segulos: What's Real and What's Not? - With Dayan Hool
1 hour 16 minutes Posted Oct 25, 2026 at 7:30 pm.
Introduction: What are segulos?
Defining segulos and distinguishing them from superstition
How mitzvos can bring specific rewards
Longevity and consistency in mitzvos
Rosh Hashanah simanim and symbolic foods
Kabbalah, false mystics, and exaggerated promises
Distinguishing healing practices from superstition
Red threads and their sources
Tehillim for someone who is ill
Paying others to daven and the role of tzedakah
The significance of forty days and a Kotel story
Rabbi Meir Baal Haness and lost objects
Providing food and drink as a segula
Segulos surrounding fertility and childbirth
Sandek and bris-related customs
Why a segula does not guarantee results
Prioritizing mitzvos and practical responsibilities
Final advice: how to evaluate a segula
0:00
1:16:16
Download MP3
Show notes
Do segulos really work? Can they guarantee a yeshuah? And how do we distinguish a genuine segulah from superstition?
From red strings and chai rotel to 40-day practices, visiting kivrei tzaddikim and paying others to daven on our behalf, segulos have become a familiar part of Jewish life. But where do these practices come from, what is their basis in Torah and Halachah, and how are they actually supposed to work?
In this fascinating and thought-provoking episode, Dayan Hool explores the origins, legitimacy and misconceptions surrounding segulos, including some surprising distinctions between accepted Jewish practices and forbidden superstitions.
And perhaps the biggest question of all: Are segulos a meaningful part of Yiddishkeit, or have we become so focused on finding shortcuts to a yeshuah that we're missing the point?
 
Timestamps: