We start by debating a big question raised in Noah Hiles’ mailbag this week: will GM Ben Cherington return in 2026—and should he? (Spoiler: we’re not so sure that’s the right move.) Next, we break down how Don Kelly has performed as interim manager and whether he deserves the job long-term. Plus, we reveal which Pirates prospects are headed to the Arizona Fall League and share what their invitations mean for the organization’s future.