Islanders fans share the stories of their favorite games. In this episode: A first Islanders-Rangers game, an unforgettable loss and a Valentines Day tradition. Callers tell us about their first New York rivalry experience, a first date that became a yearly tradition, a single regular season loss than came to define and entire era in franchise history and how a new fan was created in a flawed but important arena in Islanders history. Thanks to Stephen, Chris, William and Mike for their calls. To share your most memorable Islanders game story with us, call (646) 980-8857 anytime.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices