To be clear this is just for Maisel Goys. I loved Gilmore Guys, funny, witty, and thoughtful. Maisel Goys is basically the opposite. Every week the review is the same. Alice meanly picks on Kevin while simultaneously hating the entire premise of the show. She canât seem to find joy in anything and it made me sad to listen to, so, I stopped. Will keep the pod in my feed in case Kevin decides to do something else with someone else.
I only recently discovered the Gilmore Guys, and, just as with Gilmore Girls, I can go to any episode from any year and be entertained and intrigued. These guys are hilarious and so endearing, and itâs a feast for the ears to hear them talk about our beloved Gilmore Girls, which is arguably the best TV show and topic of conversation ever :)
Iâve listened to the Gilmore Guys episodes about 3 times now the later seasons are great for road trips or commutes as they are at LEAST 2 hours long. If youâre just starting out the first 2 seasons can be a little rough but if youâre in it for more than just the Gilmore talk they are important for âbit buildingâ as most of those come back or are referenced later on. A lot of people complain that they get off topic too much which can be true but honestly I think itâs only truly bothersome with Anthony Troli episodes because they all bro out too hard. Iâve found some of my favorite podcasts because of their guests like Song Exploder and How Did This Get Made so I really enjoy the end plugs etc. I did not like Bunheads and kind of resent watching it because Kevin talked about how great it was. Iâm not a fan of Alice Wetterlund so couldnât get through the Marvelous Mrs. Maisel eps. Finally, Kevin thinks heâs funnier than he is. He mimics a lot of the people he looks up to which is made apparent because those people come on the show and make it completely obvious...errr Jason Mantzoukas or that Aziz Voice?In the end I think this is definitely worth listening to if you like podcasts and love Gilmore Girls but just prepare yourself for a few eye roll moments.
I just got to season 3 of Reviews and Iâm thankful I hung in this long. Like Kevin said in the first episode they definitely hit their stride in season three. The guests and the two hosts seem more invested in the show at this point. Looking forward to rounding out everything and getting to Bunheads and Mrs. Maisel.
I first got into this show in early 2016, binge listened to catch up, loved it and then got to see it live. It was the second podcast I ever listened to and it is still my favorite. Pairing hilarious hosts with my favorite show was a perfect combination for me, and Iâve heard all the eps a handful of times at this point. Cannot recommend enough.
Kevin and Demi remind me of my best friend and I. Their rap game is pretty weak but their Gilmore game strong as hell so imma give it a fiver.
Making my drive to work so fun!
I loved the Gilmore Guys. But I absolutely canât stand to listen to Alice Wetterlund replacing Demi on Marvelous Mrs. Maisel. Alice was barely even an okay guest. Completely donât like the show without Demi.
Been listening to them for years, never gets old.
Sometimes the conversations are grand, sometimes they are pedantic, but they always remind me of something I love about the Gilmores.
Y'all made me fell old because I remember being a four year old when seven heaven, eight simple rules and Gilmore girls! I'm re-watching Gilmore Girls for the second time in my life because of y'all podcast being hosted by two guys who are funny!
I really like this podcast, but it drives me crazy when they say no one gets most of the references. I wish theyâd understand that they were just too young when this came out to get a lot of them. I am a woman right in between Rory and Loreleiâs ages when the show came out and I get 95% of them.
Ok, this podcast can get a bit on the longish side, HOWEVER, for every one time I feel like it might be getting a bit boring, there have been three times where I have ugly laughed hard enough to spill a drink or swerve while driving. Kevin and Demi are such a likable combination and I have found so many great comedians and influencers by following the guests of the show. Iâve been listening since early 2015 and have loved the excuse to really delve into a show that I adored as a teenager. This podcast is a gem.
I think Demi and Kevin are hilarious and have great chemistry, BUT! I think the guest hosts need to be chosen better. I feel like most of them donât like the show which is kind of annoying. Having more super fans would have been nice change.
Love this podcast. Started from the beginning about a month before the AYITL released and now a year later I have a handful of eps left. While it can get long I love the in-depth looks into my favorite tv series that I have watched multiple times. They made me realize I only like season 6 Jess for Rory and that she deserves better. And the Dean treatment! Sad! Haha.
Longtime fan. Have listened to every episode. Twice if not more. Kevin and Demi feel like my close friends, and it was so fun to see them evolve as hosts, friends, and individuals throughout the course of the show. PS- the parts where they talk about the girls are good too. But thatâs not why anyone listens.
This is my favorite podcast ever. Even if you havenât seen Gilmore Girls you should listen to this. These guys are so hilarious and creative and down to earth. My biggest regret in life is not making it to one of their live shows. ð Hereâs to hoping for a reunion!
The only thing wrong with this podcast is that Iâm not on it with you. ð Loving it!
This is a great podcast! So funny and entertaining!
Love these guys...only a 4 because they stay up topic quite a bit and it's probably funny if you're in the room with them but it just gets really annoying when you want to hear them talk about Gilmore girls I spent 15 minutes talking about something else.