I like majority of the stories that are on this podcast, but I wish the creepy thriller level was more consistent . Some are really good with different twist (like playpen. Ending was crazy) but some of these stories are so dull and boring. I also think the ads should be at the end or beginning because when the story is getting good, and it switches to an ad (like it does in secret bar) it kills the mood. Otherwise. Iâm a fan
I finally found the origin of laughing jack thanks to you! And it was pretty freaky to be honest! Can you do âEyeless jackâ by any chance because itâs a fun story to listen to. Thanks!
Zero consistency as far as quality control goes. I suppose theyâd argue that thereâs something for everyone. If only it wasnât metered on iq.
Great story teller even making the commercial great. Thanks
I would have given 5 stars but at times the background music drowns out the narrative. Other than that itâs awesome!
I've never been a fan of scary stories, but this is great storytelling...even if it is a little spooky. Great podcast.
I really enjoy this podcast, but I have to say that La Bruja was my least favorite episode
I usually cannot stand fiction or story podcasts but I am a big creepypasta fan and decided to give it a go. So glad I did! Great narration and stories, Iâve been binging all day.
Blows your mind at every turn.
I stumbled upon this podcast by chance and binge listened through every single episode. The Tales From The Gas Station are among my favorites, and you never know what to expect from a title alone, especially The Scariest Story Weâve Ever Told You. Give it a listen and if you donât care for the story told in that episode, listen to another. Theyâre all so different it hits every weird and creepy genre.
If you like this podcast you are helping people life inpacking there life so like this podcast plz OH AND APRIL FOOLS
This podcast is great! Some of my favorite stories. Keep up the great work.
Found this podcast just by chance and now I am binge listening to everything. The Ad placements are a little strange and long but other than that definitely worth subscribing to.
Look, I do enjoy this podcast for the most part. But the ad integration is obnoxious. I frequently canât tell when an ad has begun, and frankly, most of the ads sound like radio garbage. It shouldnât be that hard to put ads in your podcast that donât disrupt the content. Make them easier to skip, or at least easier to identify. If your ads are just mediocre skits, then please, spare me. If you canât, weâll, Iâll just enjoy this less. Thank you for making it, Iâll keep listening regardless.
Iâm not sure why but the last two months I have barely been able to listen to any stories. I hit play and the story never plays... sooo yeah
I love this podcast, in my opinion the narrator is good, and the storyâs are amazing
Iâm a horror junkie so I listen to all things horror, and this is by far the best one. No sleep is a good contender but the narrator on Creepy and his sound effects, ambiance, and great selection of stories is incredible, and Iâm so grateful someone made such a perfect horror podcast.
My new obsession!
Great low pitched voice extremely addictive to the background sounds makes me imagine that im there
Iâm a new comer to this channel but after listening to Playpen, I am now a subscriber. Being a writer myself, I appreciate a well written story. If all of the offerings on this channel are of the same caliber as Playpen, then I will know that I made a good decision. Thank you for the obvious hard work you put into this channel and please keep it up. Tim WhiteAberdeen, MS
I like it!Stories are creepy and the narration is good. I do recommend it. I like it!
Just not for me. Podcast host has a âSwaggerâ to his voice that doesnât sell it. Over sold and not impressed
My new favorite podcast. Love it!!
I listen to this podcast while working and I work mostly by myself and I constantly catch myself looking over my shoulder because I think Iâve heard noises while listening to these gut wrenching episodes
The narrator is dull and boring. He turns scary stories into sleepy time stories. Plus they do not take user submitted stories. They think they are too good for that. There are much better scary or creepy pasta podcasts out there. Donât waste your time here
Iâve been listening to Creepy since Oct 17 and it has remained one of my top favorite podcasts! Way to go Jon!
I came in search of something similar to the nosleep podcast and found just the right one with great narration, original musical score and weekly updated stories which fills my creepy appetite
This is scary not just creepy I love it .ALOT its odd scary and over all amazing
I canât handle the northern Midwest accent. âDraegging a daeggerâ âMaeggots â.
Ted the Caver was an excellent series. I think theyâre getting the hang of this.
Some of the tales narrated here are true, brilliant chillers. Others are typically bad written creepy pastas that lack any imagination beyond âOMG THE CALL WAS COMING FROM UPSTAIRS!â Even some of the really, really good ones are overburdened with explicit plot holes (Dear Abby is an excellent example) whereas others are just Welcome to Nightvale knockoffs, like the âgas stationâ series. Still, you can find some great things on here.
These stories never disappoint. The narrator has a unique cadence that draws you in leaves you wanting more.
Iâd admit everyone I shared this with hasnât loved it. The narrations can be hit or miss depending on the story. Iâve listened to well over 20 hours of their material and can say more than 16 hours, I have enjoyed.
I love this podcast, you bring the story to life in such a chilling way. The only down side is not enough! Love the content, love the narration, keep coming with the amazing stuff!
Ok, so it was around halloween and I was looking at podcasts because I recently found out what they were so I decided to give it a shot I wanted to listen scary stories and I found this Podcast. I clicked on the episode âThe Lost Episodesâ (My favorite) and was impressed and kept listening and now here I am.
But let down... that lisp makes it unbearable to listen to. If youâre narrating a podcast maybe not have a speech impediment.
Listening to the story A small piece of lead and was really turned off hearing the ân wordâ thrown in so unnecessarily. It added nothing to the story, was really out of place, and awkward. I think the narrator should have omitted it. Iâm unsubscribed now because i canât support a show that thinks it is okay.
The narratorâs voice is relaxing not boring! I just started listening and I really enjoy the stories. Thanks for the hard work!
I liked this podcast for its creepy scary stories but lately they have been revolving around suicide way to often. Having a close friend who died by suicide I cannot listen to these stories anymore.
Scary stories have no happy ending. Some of these are just plain boring and not intense. The commercials in the middle of the stories break the tension. Get Dr Creepen to narrorate the stories
Just horrible. That Midwest accent is dreadful
Really tried to like it... but random racial slurs are a buzzkill.
Not censoring content is what makes the story truly terrifying.
Love the production value! I sometimes have to take my earbuds out at work because I canât tell if itâs the podcast or someone in my office. I listen to a lot of creepy podcasts with background noise/music/etc., and Iâve never had that experience before (Not being able to tell if itâs in my real world or not). Iâve been listening two days and already recommended it to two people. The guest readers are incredible too! My only critique is that the intro and outro are a little cheesy. But I feel like that helps sometimes, a little cheese to cut the âis this real or not?â. Either way, itâs great! Canât wait to catch up to current episodes!
A story on child porn, REALLY! I am done with this podcast. They should be reported! Negative stars if that was possible!
I enjoy the narration and the length of the stories. Perfect for my commute. Good caliber of story telling and content.
This podcast is great
I've been listening to this podcast for a while now. I've always loved a good scary story and this podcast always has them. I finally became a Patreon member and let me tell you what, out of all the podcasts I support thru Patreon, this one gives me the most for my donation. Utterly amazing! Thank you for all your hard work and dedication. It's not easy consistently putting out high quality content, but you are doing it! -jen from Our True Crime Podcast